Carnegie (postcode 3163) sits 12 kilometres south-east of the Melbourne CBD inside the City of Glen Eira, on the Cranbourne and Pakenham rail lines between Caulfield and Oakleigh. Its SEIFA IRSAD score of 1090 places it in decile 9 of 10 nationally and at the 89th percentile within Victoria, firmly in the advantaged band. That reading reflects a population with above-average incomes, lower unemployment, and stronger household resources relative to most Australian suburbs. For investors, the score is a useful macro anchor, but it is the starting point of analysis, not the conclusion.
ABS 2021 IRSAD release. Score 1090 (national mean = 1000).
A decile 9 SEIFA reading carries real weight inside the PropertyRanker model. It contributes positively to the economic_strength criterion, signalling a tenant and owner-occupier base with resilience through economic cycles. It also reduces the hazard_risk and entry_point_risk flags that disadvantaged postcodes attract, because areas with stronger household resources tend to show lower rates of mortgage stress and forced sales. Those three criteria sit on the macro side of the model and Carnegie scores well on all of them from this reading alone.
The practical consequence for strategy matching is important to understand. Carnegie is a well-established, tightly held suburb with high land values and a demographic profile that attracts owner-occupiers as much as renters. Gross yields at this end of the socioeconomic spectrum tend to compress well below the 5 percent anchor of the Balanced strategy and further still from the 6 to 7 percent anchors of the High Yield and Regional strategies. The suburb's profile is most consistent with a Capital Growth orientation, where the gross-yield anchor sits around 3.5 percent and the thesis rests on long-run land value appreciation rather than income return. Investors targeting yield above 5 percent should verify current asking rents and vacancy data carefully before assuming Carnegie fits their model, because the postcode-level SEIFA reading cannot confirm that a specific listing clears their yield hurdle. Apartment and unit stock within the same postcode can present different yield profiles from detached houses, so product type matters as much as suburb.
Carnegie VIC 3163 house prices have shown modest movement over the past 12 months, with propertyvalue.com.au reporting a median house sale price of approximately $1.8M and annual growth of +2.9%, while yourinvestmentpropertymag.com.au (as of April 2026) recorded a median of $1,677,500 with -1.32% annual growth, reflecting some divergence across data providers and periods. The average vendor discount for houses sits at -6.0% per propertyvalue.com.au, and days on market average around 31 days per the same source. Woodards.com.au reports house days on market up 27.1% year-on-year to 61 days, and sales volume for houses down 9.2% to 158 over 12 months, pointing to a softening sales environment even as prices hold near historic highs.
Anchor points pulled per refresh from publicly available suburb profiles. Approximate; not a moving average.
Days on market are up 27.1% year-on-year per Woodards and vendor discounts remain elevated at -6.0% per propertyvalue.com.au, while vacancy at 1.74% (htag.com.au) is stable, placing the market in a cool band with two of three signals softening.
Sources: Carnegie VIC 3163 Suburb Profile & Property Report (2026-04-01); Carnegie House Prices & Property Trends (2026-01-01); Carnegie VIC Property Market & House Prices - Woodards (2026-01-01); Free Suburb Report for Carnegie VIC 3163 - AuPropertyReport (2026-04-16); Carnegie VIC 3163 Property Market and House Prices 2026 - HTAG (2026-01-01) · Refreshed 8 Oct 2026
PropertyRanker scores any Australian property against 12 criteria across three pillars: Growth, Cashflow, and Risk. SEIFA is a primary signal for economic strength and a supporting one for entry-price risk. It also informs the crime side of hazard risk, though physical overlays like flood, bushfire and coastal exposure, and recorded crime data where available, take priority there. The decile of 9 shown above gives a listing in Carnegie a stronger starting line on economic strength than the national median postcode, and a softer one on entry-price risk, since more advantaged postcodes usually carry higher entry prices.
On top of that, PropertyRanker chooses one of four strategies (Balanced, Growth, Yield, Regional) and applies a per-strategy yield anchor. The anchors are 3.5% for Growth, 5% for Balanced, 6% for Yield, and 7% for Regional. A postcode at this level of relative advantage tends to suit the Growth (3.5% anchor) and Balanced (5% anchor) strategies more readily than Yield (6%) or Regional (7%), because a higher entry price compresses the gross yield a listing can reach without a specific value-add.
Read the scoring guide for the full criteria list and how the verdict thresholds work.
A strong SEIFA reading does not make every listing in Carnegie a sound investment, and a weak individual listing does not erase the macro advantage the score provides. Before scoring a specific property, investors should confirm the current SQM vacancy rate for postcode 3163, because even advantaged suburbs can carry pockets of oversupply in high-density unit blocks. Body corporate financials and sinking fund balances are critical for any strata title, and Carnegie has seen medium and high-density development that makes this check non-negotiable. Flood and planning overlay status should be checked at the individual lot level through the Glen Eira planning portal, as low-lying pockets near drainage lines can carry overlays that affect insurability and future development potential. Finally, price the listing against recent comparable sales in the same street or block rather than suburb-wide medians, because within a 3.8 square kilometre suburb the variance between a renovated house on a large block and a dated unit can be substantial. Run the specific listing through PropertyRanker to get a verdict that accounts for all twelve scoring criteria, including the live signals this postcode-level SEIFA reading cannot see.
Carnegie's SEIFA IRSAD score of 1090 (decile 9 nationally, 89th percentile in Victoria) signals a strong socioeconomic base, which supports the economic_strength and entry_point_risk criteria in PropertyRanker's model. That macro advantage does not automatically make every listing a sound investment; product type, current vacancy, and pricing against comparable sales all matter at the individual level. The suburb suits investors whose thesis is long-run land value rather than immediate income return, but each listing needs to be scored on its own merits.
Carnegie's high SEIFA decile and tightly held, high-value land profile align most closely with PropertyRanker's Capital Growth strategy, which anchors around a 3.5 percent gross yield. The High Yield strategy (around 6 percent) and Regional strategy (around 7 percent) are unlikely to be met by typical house stock in this postcode without a specific structural reason such as a dual-income configuration. Investors targeting yields above 5 percent should verify current asking rents for the specific product type before assuming the suburb fits a Balanced or High Yield frame.
The primary risk for investors in Carnegie is yield compression: a decile 9 SEIFA suburb with high land values tends to produce gross yields well below the national average, which can create negative cash flow exposure depending on financing structure. Medium and high-density unit stock carries additional strata-specific risks, including body corporate levies and sinking fund adequacy, that the postcode-level SEIFA score cannot detect. Planning overlays and flood-prone pockets within the suburb boundary are lot-specific and must be checked through the Glen Eira planning portal for any individual address.
PropertyRanker uses the SEIFA IRSAD reading as a primary input for three of its twelve scoring criteria: economic_strength, hazard_risk, and entry_point_risk. Carnegie's score of 1090 (90 points above the national mean of 1000) contributes positively to all three criteria at the macro level. The remaining nine criteria draw on listing-level and live data signals, including SQM vacancy rates, body corporate health, flood and planning overlay status, and pricing against recent comparable sales, none of which the SEIFA score can see. Scoring the specific listing in PropertyRanker is the only way to get a verdict that combines both the macro and the property-level picture.
Carnegie, Murrumbeena, and Glen Huntly all share postcode 3163 and sit within the same City of Glen Eira LGA, so their macro SEIFA context is closely related. Oakleigh (3166) to the south-east is a distinct postcode with a different SEIFA profile and has historically offered lower entry prices, which can affect yield and entry_point_risk scores differently in PropertyRanker's model. Investors comparing these suburbs should score individual listings in each postcode rather than relying on suburb-level generalisations, because price, vacancy, and overlay conditions can diverge meaningfully even across adjacent boundaries.
Paste a real address. Get a defensible verdict across 12 criteria in around three minutes.
Score a property free